COPTIC AND CELTIC: THE LEGACY OF ST ANTHONY OF EGYPT

In late Roman Egypt, Christian hermits were treated like rock stars. The subsequently sainted Anthony of Egypt had this treatment and did not like it. He tried fleeing ever deeper into the desert “in an effort to escape the attentions of a stream of adoring Gaeco-Roman intellectuals from Alexandria … who revered him for his earthy asceticism and his reputed power over demons. These sophisticates had turned up in streams at St Anthony’s cave, causing the baffled hermit – a painfully shy man who had retreated into the sand dunes with the express purpose of avoiding other human beings – to flee from his admirers further and further into the desert.
“Eventually, when his fan club pursued him into … some of the most inhospitable sand-wastes in the entire Middle East, the saint realised that he was never going to shake off his followers. He decided instead to organise them into a loose-knit community of hermits, over which he kept watching from a cave a safe distance further up the mountain.
So was born Christian monasticism, and with incredible speed the idea spread.” (1)
By the early 5th century, there were 700 monasteries between Jerusalem and the Byzantine southern border. A book recounting St Anthony’s life was translated into Latin and monasticism spread to western Europe. It became especially popular in Italy and the South of France.
By 700 it had reached the highlands of Scotland: “an image of St Anthony under a palm tree was sculpted by Pictish monks on the windswept promontory of Nigg near Inverness, hundreds of miles beyond the Roman Empire’s onetime northernmost border”.
According to William Dalrymple (1), the Celtic connection with Egyptian Coptic tradition is thought to be particularly strong: “The reason for my particular interest in the icons of St Anthony was that during the Dark Ages the saint was also a favourite subject for the Pictish artists of my native Scotland, as well as for those across the sea in Ireland. The Celtic monks of both countries consciously looked on St Anthony as their ideal and their prototype, and the proudest boast of Celtic monasticism was that, in the words of the 7th century Antophonary of the Irish monastery of Bangor:
This house full of delight
Is built on the rock
And indeed the true vine
Transplanted out of Egypt.”
Dalrymple points to similarities between Celtic and Coptic churches, not shared by other Western Churches:
bishops with crowns, not mitres
T shaped Tau crosses rather than crooks or croziers
Early use of hand-bells
The Celtic Wheel cross is now understood to have been a Coptic image, known from a 5th century burial pall, three centuries before appearing in Ireland or Scotland.
There is also a famous Coptic icon depicting St Anthony and his friend St Paul the Hermit’s sitting opposite each other in St Paul’s cave, breaking bread. Exactly the same image, dated in the 7th century CE, is found on a Pictish stone.
This is not as odd as it may seem. In the period after the Roman Empire fell in the West, and the Anglo-Saxons occupied the much of Southern and Eastern England, the Celtic peoples of Britain and Ireland could stlll sail to the Mediterranean and trade with the Eastern Roman (Byzantine) Empire, as far as Constatinople and Alexandria. Tintagel, in Cornwall, was for a time a considerable port. The kings of Dumnonia (Cornwall and Devon) gave themselves names like Constantine and David to emphasise their links with Christian Roman tradition. They also maintained links with Christian communities throughout Western Britain and Ireland. The early development of monasticism in the Celtic churches is a testament to the power and value of a new overseas cultural influence in challenging times.
(1) William Dalrymple From the Holy Mountain: A Journey in the Shadow of Byzantium London: HarperCollins Publishers, 1997 (Kindle edition).
NOTE: The Holy Mountain is primarily a comparison of Christianity in the Byzantine Empire before the rise of Islam, and the situation as it stood in 1994. Dalrymple repeated the journey of a monk, John Moschos, at the end of the 6th century. It was documented by John Moschos as The Spiritual Meadow of John Moschos. Dalrymple travelled with a paperback translation to hand. His own journey took him through modern Turkey, Syria, Lebanon, Israel/Palestine and Egypt. On the whole, Dalrymple found dwindling, pessimistic Christian communities. Many had faced significant discrimination and were concerned about their future. Many, indeed, had emigrated or were contemplating emigration, though some Christians in some places were doing well. My understanding is that the situation overall has further deteriorated over the last 30 years.




























